Having graduated from the University of CO Boulder, Shelby fell in love with Colorado but always dreamt of exploring the Big Apple. After 6 years in NYC she took 2 years to travel the world. Hitting her 40th country she knew it was time to move back to Denver. With her inner East Coast and extensive experience in Airbnb Management, she was ready to be a Realtor®.

After joining New Era, Shelby jumped right into her first 10 transactions, with a few months to go in 2020 earning recognition as the “Rising Star”. Her goal with each client has always been to create an experience while helping find the ultimate dream home, investment property or next project. There’s something for everyone looking to gain equity and increase their net-worth over time.

When you work with Shelby, you have someone on your team ensuring the deal will get done. Passionate, knowledgeable and a large network of resources- She makes it happen!

My Listings

My Testimonials

Submit your review

Create your own review

New Era Group
Average rating:  
 12 reviews
by zuser20160217113745246 on New Era Group
Bought a Single Family home in 2020 in Colorado Springs, CO

Shelby has found her calling as an incredible realtor! Her bubbly, positive attitude is matched perfectly by her fierce drive and initiative. I felt well guided from start to finish and quickly realized, even as a first-time home buyer, that I was in the best hands. We took a few tries to find a home that fit my requirements and budget but Shelby was never discouraged or pressured me to change my criteria, we just pressed on and before I knew it, we had closed on my dream home! I feel so grateful to have worked with Shelby Crissman and you will be too!

by Stewart Brandon on New Era Group
Bought a Townhouse home in 2020 in Lakewood, CO

My experience with Shelby was excellent. Truly second to none service! She made the entire home buying process such a breeze! Shelby is extremely knowledgeable and highly professional. Her passion for this industry really shows she cares for her clients, and she will exhaust all resources to help you find your dream home. Throughout the entire process she was extremely patient, always easy to contact, and respectful. Look no further if you’re in the market to buy a home. I am incredibly happy with my new home and thankful Shelby was by my side the entire way. I highly recommend Shelby.

by jccvllc on New Era Group
Bought a Single Family home in 2020 in Denver, CO

I had a great experience buying my duplex with Shelby. She showed me many properties over multiple days before I found the perfect one. She was professional, quick to respond, and very knowledgeable. I highly recommend using her

by devin937 on New Era Group
Consulted me on buying or selling a home in Northwestern Denver

Working in the industry, I can say with conviction that Shelby is best. Her individual approach with every one of her clients, and her understanding and knowledge of the market from a macro and micro level makes her the person you want representing you. Not to mention she always makes the process fun which it should be! If you are looking to buy or sell in this market, do yourself a favor and give Shelby a call.

by lpatte2 on New Era Group

Shelby is fantastic. She is dedicated to finding her clients the best properties on the market by doing the following:
1. She meets with her clients before starting the process to get to know them and their needs/wants in a home.
2. Immediately sets up an MLS account based on client feedback so that her clients get real time data on the housing market.
3. She also drives the streets of Denver to search for "Coming Soon" listings and is well connected to get off the market deals.
4. Shelby will also go tour homes and send videos with feedback when clients aren't available to ensure her clients don't miss out on a great home.
5. She's responsive and is always available to help her clients in anyway they need (advice on buying, selling, comparing houses, lending, inspection, etc.)

Shelby gets the job done for her clients and I highly recommend using her!

by Tucker Wilde on New Era Group

10/10 experience with Shelby, first time buyers, highly recommend, quick & painless close!

Shelby is a tenacious and hungry realtor who understood our vision and found our dream property! She was essential in our process as we were looking for a diamond in the rough and had been searching for almost 3 years prior to finding her. She kept us on (an expedited) track, communicated well, and made sure we understood the process.

Shelby has quickly become a close friend of ours and saw our purchase through from start to finish.

Thank you Shelby!

by zuser20160205091302668 on New Era Group
Highly likely to recommend

I worked with Shelby to buy my first house. I have worked with other realtors in the past and feel that they didn't take as much personal time to understand my needs and find the right fit. With Shelby, every time I found 1 house I liked, she would have 5 more lined up to tour. She was always on the look out for the perfect fit, and thankfully we found it fairly quickly. The house was only on the market 24 hours and Shelby helped build out a bid that won over the 10 other bids on the house. She is always quick to respond, even to my questions 4 months later! I would highly recommend working with Shelby.

by spr303 on New Era Group
Highly likely to recommend |

Working with Shelby was a great experience from beginning to end as a first time home buyer. She was able to provide a thorough overview of the whole process and then quickly got me set up with the search tool needed to narrow my selections. Shelby was very patient as we viewed a number of properties and was very responsive throughout the process. Her successful negotiations made the final decision much more appealing. I would recommend her to anyone looking for a real estate expertise in Colorado!

by Hunter Phillips on New Era Group
Highly likely to recommend

Shelby was a godsend when it came to buying my first house. She took the time to walk me through each step of the process, carefully explaining everything I needed to know and answering all of my questions. I didn't have a specific neighborhood in mind when we first started looking, but she was more than happy to explore every corner of the city to ensure we found the right home. She was always available when I had questions and was extremely communicative throughout the whole process.

Within two months, she helped me find the perfect home for a great price. Her knowledge of the market, professionalism, and willingness to go above and beyond for her clients truly sets her apart. I would highly recommend Shelby as an agent if you are looking to buy in the greater Denver area.

by Kassidy Fitzpatrick on New Era Group
Highly likely to recommend

My husband and I loved working with Shelby in finding our first home. She was not only very professional and responsive to all of our needs, but also kept our best interests in mind as we're welcoming our first child in May.

When it came to negotiating, Shelby pulled out all the stops for us. We were able to complete the closing process with nothing but positive vibes and excitement.

Shelby is very attentive to everything you are looking for and is realistic and knowledgeable in her conversations about what is out in the market. She dedicates all of her time in looking at the new housing market trends and keeps her clients and audience up to date with that information on her instagram account @withshleby which was SUPER helpful to us.

We would recommend her to anyone looking for a new home in the Denver CO area or surrounding.

by Jen Keane on New Era Group
Highly likely to recommend |

If you are looking to purchase a new home, you need Shelby on your Team! She is incredibly knowledgeable about all that Denver and Colorado have to offer. She is extremely driven, accommodating, communicative, and always looking out for your best interest. It's a competitive market and she went out of her way to make sure we secured our house. Her commitment to her clients is unreal and made my husband and I feel so comfortable buying our first home. With Shelby, the process was seamless, especially for first-time buyers overwhelmed by the entire process. Couldn't ask for a better realtor!!

by haydenpaulanderson0 on New Era Group
Highly likely to recommend

Shelby is not one of the best, she is the best. From the start she was familiar with the market, areas and sought to understand my wants as a buyer. With the competitiveness of the market in Colorado you need someone like Shelby on your side. She will do everything she can within your budget to get you under contract. She cares about you as an individual and actually getting you in a home you want. Even after the closing process she was and is there. She not only will become your friend through your home buying process, but the weapon you will need in the one of the most competitive markets in the nation!